MovieChat Forums > Yellowstone (2018) Discussion > "The Godfather on a ranch." Seriously?

"The Godfather on a ranch." Seriously?


Mario Puzo's "The Godfather" was a great book & Francis Coppola's screen adaptation was a great movie with some great actors. Kostner is okay but he's no Brando & "Yellowstone" . . . ? Hardly.

I guess I can see where they are trying, though. Kaycie (forgive the spelling) is supposed to be Michael Corleone, Jamie is supposed to be Fredo (& it won't surprise me one bit when, in an upcoming season, one of the Dutton's or Rip whacks him), Rip is either Sonny C. or Luca Brasi. I haven't figured out who Beth is yet. Maybe she is supposed to be Sonny, & that would definitely make Rip Luca B. (without the attraction between the two of them). But I wish the writer's would figure out a way to write her out of the script, preferably to kill her so she won't come back.

reply

Thinking about it some more, I guess that recent episode where the Duttons hung the Becks' hired thugs up outside the Becks' ranch house (after the attack on Beth) with the "return to sender" sign on them, was probably fashioned after Jack Woltz (in "The Godfather") waking up with the Arabian Stallion head in his bed because he wouldn't give Johnny Fontane the part in the movie. (I read somewhere that Jack Woltz was Jack Warner & Fontane was Frank Sinatra.)

Just an average night at The Dutton Ranch.

I had a couple of minor nits with that episode. You would think that with as many enemies the Beck brothers have, they would have pretty good security around their pad. But since they didn't, & since the Duttons are quite comfortable with, & skilled at, killing people, & since they intend to bump the Becks off anyway, why didn't they just go ahead & do it the night they hung the thugs up outside the door?

Also, at the end of the assault on Beth when Rip came crashing in, the thug that was (at the time) in the process of assaulting Beth, got off two rounds at Rip & at least 1 (if not both) hit him. I promise you that the thug was not packing a .25 or a .32 or a 380. I am sure that in that line of work he was carrying a 9mm or a .40 or a .45 ACP, or maybe something as exotic as a Sig .357.
One of my earlier thoughts on this series is that Hauser doesn't do a bad job at making Rip into a truly dangerous sociopath; however, ascribing super human qualities to him didn't (imo) do the show any good. I suppose the doc that Dutton called to do some battle field surgery sans the hospital may have successfully worked on Rip in his office, but after two whacks in the torso from (at the very least) a 9mm & ensuing surgery, I am pretty sure Rip would have needed some blood products. I haven't seen a Dr.s office yet equipped for administering blood.

reply

You're not giving Costner his due here. I think he's a great actor and that he does a great job on the show. He's better than "okay." In fact, I'd say that Costner in general is kind of underrated these days and I'm glad to see that in the last five or so years he's managed to make something of a career comeback. I grew up watching him in films like Field of Dreams and Robin Hood and Dances With Wolves and have always been a fan. As good as he was then, he's even better now.

reply

I haven't watched a whole lot of Kevin Costner up until now. "Swing vote" was Costner, right? I remember "Water World" & some flick where he was pitching for the Tigers & threw a no-hitter. None of those blew me away, but it was probably more the films than Costner's acting.

What I will say for "Yellowstone" is that Costner's portrayal of a crusty, salty old rancher (I have known a couple) who has spent his life in the elements with his animals comes off as quite realistic to me (that is, when he is not plotting &/or conspiring to perpetrate some bizarrely nefarious scheme). & I'll repeat that Cole Hauser (Rip) comes off as a believably scary sociopath (that is, when he is not being impervious to being shot at close range with a 9mm or greater), the likes of whom I knew a couple & tried not to antagonize, especially when they were drinking.

I feel that Costner's decent portrayal of the a fore mentioned rancher will forever be lessened by the far out events & goings on that he has to be a part of, in the series.

"The Godfather On A Ranch" is how Paramount advertises this, &, imo, what Costner is doing in Yellowstone is not nearly in the same league as what Brando did in "The Godfather." But I will repeat from my last reply, different strokes, & add that: perhaps I like to take things too literally.

You are a good sport, so continue enjoying.

reply