MovieChat Forums > John Wick: Chapter 2 (2017) Discussion > Sister slashing her wrists scene

Sister slashing her wrists scene


Did you guys stretch uncomfortably in your seat, too? It was fine for 30 seconds or so, then it just stretched on and on with her bleeding for minutes at a time. I was like, "we need to watch THE WHOLE THING?"



reply

Nope

reply

A guy next to me covered his eyes and said "ouch". LOL.


Lose the Game!!!!!!!

reply

Yeah, that was hard to watch.

Further more, I was hoping that he wouldn't kill the bad guy's sister.. she's somewhat innocent. I felt bad that she had to commit suicide .. and to top it off, he shot her in the head while she was dead? that's just mean.

John should have found another way to get out of that marker... Alas.

reply

She wasnt innocent , she was a mob boss, and i guess the bullet was to make sure the wrist cutting wasnt some sort of Penn & Teller illusion lol

reply

The bullet was to fulfill his marker contract, officially. His job wasn't to sit back and watch her die by suicide, it was to kill her himself.

re: the topic- even John Wick himself winced a little as he watched her cutting into her wrist.

reply

I find this scene to be one of the strongest in the film. It’s slow, quite, a bit uneasy to watch and just feels relatively out of place compared to the rest of the film. And, it is done so effectively.

Now as Giana wasn’t going to be given the option to live, she chose to take her own life and perhaps save Wick from this one sin. At the same time, one could argue she wanted Wick to witness this closely - and slowly - to maybe have him question if this was all really worth it (mind you, John was clearly disturbed by what Giana decided to to). John eventually decides to shoot her (whether she was already dead by that point or not is beside the point) because it was his marker that he had to fulfill.

reply

Leading up to her death, she asked Wick if he feared eternal damnation to which answered yes. She said that she thought that she would avoid damnation. She is Italian. She is probably Roman Catholic. Suicide is a sin and she would have ended up in hell.

John has already commited so many sins and is going to hell, anyways. By shooting and killing her as she was fading, he spared her from damnation, at least for this particular sin.

reply