MovieChat Forums > It Comes at Night (2017) Discussion > Shame on you Joel Edgerton

Shame on you Joel Edgerton


It's SO OBVIOUS that Joel Edgerton thought to himself after staring in the 2011 remake of John Carpenter's "The Thing" that he could copy the story and do the very same thing on a small budget and set in a different scenario and deluded himself into thinking it would work!

"The Thing but in the woods" checklist by Joel Edgerton:

1 - An infected dog (check)
2 - Anxiety of not knowing if and who is infected (check)
3 - Must end with the only 2 survivors sat opposite each other asking themselves "what was the point of all that then!"

Fill it out with:

Family in the foods, person breaks in, family rescue intruders family, dog runs away from home, dog returns infected, someone lets the dog back in, intruders family are killed trying to leave, family eventually die of infection.

No background story, no character development, no hint at the bigger picture of their predicament, just no bloody point to any of it whatsoever.

How a movie like this gets green lighted in this day and age speaks volumes about the state 'Hollywood' is truly in.

Shame on you Joel Edgerton, shame on you.

reply

You're dumb, man. Really, really dumb. Sorry.

reply

still a pretty good movie

reply

Your disdain for this film is perplexing. I mean, it ain't the greatest thing I've ever seen by any means, but it a'ight enough. Surely you can spend your invaluable mental energy dogging something truly bad? Sigh, carry on.

reply

To call this film shit would be an insult to shit !!!!!!

reply


I disagree. I thoroughly enjoyed it, and give it a 7.5/10. It was a very intense and intelligent film, and didn't have your run of the mill movie "monster". "It" is fear, anxiety, mistrust, paranoia and nightmares, which all come at night.

😎

reply