So now you're completely changing the subject. What happened to your narrative about a Gazan searching for family under rubble? Did I make you realize it wasn't all that compelling? Your new story is even less compelling. It's actually quite obnoxious because you're bringing up issues that I already addressed on this forum or that I even discussed directly with you.
You talk about the Jewish belief that the land of Israel belongs to the Jews as if the Palestinians don't believe the exact same thing in reverse, that they have a religious belief that the land of Palestine belongs to them. Hamas believes that they're religiously obligated to fight Israel until Muslims regain control over all of Palestine. And Hamas also believes that Muslims should conquer the entire world. It's a common belief among Muslims that they should conquer the entire world. Islam started with the attempt to conquer the entire world, grabbing millions of square miles of land. The Muslims quickly got rid of all the non-Muslims from their holy land of Arabia and as a result Saudi Arabia is now an 830,000 square mile state that bans non-Muslims from citizenship. And the Palestinians shamefully expect Saudi Arabia to help them. Turnabout is fair play.
You talk about a Palestinian losing his home as if it's morally beyond the pale when it's actually quite normal for people all over the world. Jews have been forced out of their homes numerous times in numerous place over the last 2,000 years. As I already explained to you, the Arab states did this to hundreds of thousands of Jews after Israel was established. And the Palestinians shamefully expected these countries to help them. This was even done to Jews inside Palestine. When Jordan conquered the West Bank and East Jerusalem in 1948 all the Jews in those areas were forced out of their homes. Even Palestinians themselves have done that to Jews. After the 1929 Hebron pogrom the survivors were forced to leave that city. The Palestinians have even less respect for Jewish home ownership rights than the Israelis do for Palestinian home ownership rights. Turnabout is fair play.
There are NOT 8 million Palestinian refugees. Most of the actual refugees are no longer alive. The vast majority of those 8 million people are actually the *descendants* of refugees. I never said that "anything goes in war". I only said that necessary actions that actually help win the war are justified. See the difference? And Hamas massacring a thousand Israeli civilians didn't do anything to help them win their war against Israel. Hamas has now retreated to its tunnels in Gaza and is now militarily weaker than it was before the attack on Israel.
What happens to Palestinian homes is a result of the Mideast's zero-sum politics. It's all a matter of what ethnic or sectarian group is in charge of a country. No court on Earth, no matter how fair or unfair it is, can do anything to change that.
The original sin is the zero-sum politics of the Mideast which forced the Jews to fight and win a war for survival against the surrounding Arabs.
reply
share