MovieChat Forums > The Black Hole (1979) Discussion > So, we have Jim, Spock, Bones, Uhura and...

So, we have Jim, Spock, Bones, Uhura and.. uh... Chekhov? (spoilers)


I couldn't help but notice how Forster is pretty much quiet Jim Y Kirk, Perkins is star-stricken Spock, very flawed Bones is Borgnine and Uhura is telepathic. Not sure who the kid/cowboy would be in this comparison? Chekhov? The good doppelganger of Borgnine's cowardly Bones?
Bob the robot is unique. I'll give 'em that.

reply

I tend to see Harry Booth as more of a Harry Mudd-type, and the two characters conveniantly have the same first names. Kate reminds me more of a Nurse Chapel or a Yeoman Rand than an Uhura, her extrasensory perception notwithstanding. Durant seems more like Dr. McCoy than Spock, as he tends to blunder upon the secrets of the 'Cygnus', rather than discover them through any investigative talents of his own. Pizer and Holland both seem to share different aspects of Captain Kirk's character, so if there is a correlation, it has to be with the 'Enemy Within' Kirk(s). For my money, Holland seems to me to be more like Spock- unemotional, unflappable, and slightly detached from the action. Thus we do, indeed, have a subtext of the original 'Star Trek' operating here: namely, that if Spock were permanently in command of the 'Enterprise', it would surely have flown down some black hole, likely never to be seen again.

reply

"The Palomino...it just...died..."

Quien es mas macho?

Benedict Cumberbatch

O

Ricardo Montalban


reply

Loco. 'Yack' Lord es mas macho.

reply

by Alfabeta ยป Tue Jul 23 2013 16:58:27
IMDb member since June 2005
I couldn't help but notice how Forster is pretty much quiet Jim Y Kirk, Perkins is star-stricken Spock, very flawed Bones is Borgnine and Uhura is telepathic. Not sure who the kid/cowboy would be in this comparison? Chekhov? The good doppelganger of Borgnine's cowardly Bones?
Bob the robot is unique. I'll give 'em that.

I don't see it. They do seem like stock characters, but I wouldn't call them copies of Trek's crew.

reply

Vincent reminds me of Data.

Fasten your seatbelts, it's going to be a bumpy night.

reply

Perkins even says 'FASINATING' when looking at the black hole

reply

Kid cowboy/Han Solo
Vincent/Data
Kate/Troi
Reinheart/Khan
Reinheart crew/Borg
Maximillion/Nomad

reply