MovieChat Forums > Mad Max Beyond Thunderdome (1985) Discussion > 45 minutes of brilliance then....

45 minutes of brilliance then....


It really is like nothing I've ever seen in a movie before. I remember seeing this movie in the theater when it came out. I was 13 years old at the time and I think still feel the same way. Never have I seen a movie that could draw me in so much and then let me down just as much. Thunderdome, Bartertown, Master Blaster, Tina Turner and lots more odd and interesting characters make the first 45 minutes of this film among the best I have ever seen only to be let down by the plot of Captain Walker, Tomorrow morrow land and just a bunch of kids and stories that just seemed an excuse to explain things more. I guess my point is I think the movie would have worked so much better without hearing these stories and gone off in a much more interesting direction. Does it ruin the movie? It kind of does for me. While this is only my opinion I love discussing the movie with people. It means something different to everyone but most I have talked to agree that it loses its focus. I am by all means no screenwriter but I think the majority of Mad Max fans could have watched fights in thunderdome and a lot of great creative violent matches while possibly piecing together a much better resolution for the rest of the movie and called this a masterpiece. I don't even think it would have taken too much effort. It just hurts to see what I feel could have been one of the all time greatest movie achievements. Only my opinion. I do not try to force people into not liking the movie just feel that it was so great and then went bad.

reply

[deleted]

Max couldn't kill a child.

reply

You are the deluded one, since you can't seem to see the brilliance of the contrasting worlds of Bartertown and the "Eden" in which the children dwell. The children (and adults) who struck out for a new world, brought hope to the story, where Bartertown would probably have continued to rot in the desert. The Waiting Ones lifted the spirits of this film! How on earth could you think otherwise?

reply

I think the OP brought up some fair points about MMBT. The movie was great for the first 45 min and then drags for the next 35 min with the 'Lord of the Flies' kids, but in my opinion the movie picks back up for the last 25 min when Max goes back to Bartertown and they have the final chase.

Watching this film again for the first time in about 10 years the Kids segment didn't bother me as much as it used to, but I think that segment could easily get trimmed by 10 min to make a quicker paced film at 1hr 35min which would match the length of the previous two films and would make for a better film overall. Some one should make a fan edit of this and see how much better it would be.



http://youtu.be/8UHqdVJvk08

reply

[deleted]

Just revisited the film again, and I absolutely agree. This was going to be a great ending to a classic post-apocalyptic trilogy. It teased us for almost an hour, and then the kids showed up. Turned into some cheesy Peter Pan knockoff.


Action Hero's Anthem
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y9Cpb61R-4U

reply