MovieChat Forums > Platoon (1987) Discussion > Why all the hate for Barnes...

Why all the hate for Barnes...


... because of his madness and the gunning down of a VC granny.

But in Full Metal Jacket everyone doesn't seem to mind "Animal Mother" gunning down random folks in a rice field for no reason other than insanity.

reply

Barnes is a soldier, period.

He didn't fail his platoon when they got wiped out. It's insane to even think that they "won" that battle. He's a warrior, and his job is to kill the enemy.

Talk all the smack you want about "he failed in his role" - I'd take a company full of Barnes type soldiers over anything else anyday.

reply

I detest Barnes because he seems to enjoy it all.

While he probably hates where he is in the world, he nevertheless seems to relish the opportunity.

Meanwhile, Elias is the true soldier, with the same exact predicament & resume as Barnes, only he respects his fellow solider & the cause.

reply

White hero! that is why.All White soldiers are tougher,braver than Negroes.
Personal experience.

reply

[deleted]

No that was a guy who was supposed to be on Aliens & chose instead to go with FMJ; Animal Mother is the Big Guy with the M60 machinegun.



Why can't you wretched prey creatures understand that the Universe doesn't owe you anything!?

reply