MovieChat Forums > The Whistleblower (2011) Discussion > The torture scene

The torture scene

posted 13 years ago by PhilipSeymourHoffman
33 replies | jump to latest

So what exactly did they do to her? They didn't show it explicitly, they only showed reaction shots. Any ideas?

Keep your lovin' brother happy.

[–] katentek 12 years ago

Whats the difference what they did to her ... it was extremely painful, terrifying to the other girls and degrading ... Isn't that enough for you to know? Or maybe you are one of those morons who feel everything has to be shown explicitly nowadays to be powerful and dramatic ... or are you just a voyeur who likes to see women sexually abused. Whatever the answer I say grow up and get some morals.

"Science is the poetry of reality." Richard Dawkins

[–] PhilipSeymourHoffman 12 years ago

Believe it or not when I saw this a year ago I didn't think vaginal penetration could possibly be painful, so I thought the scene was too melodramatic and I had to be missing something. Of course since then I have learned about punching the cervix etc etc. Apparently it hurts a lot (not to sound patronizing).

Keep your lovin' brother happy.

[–] lozza_dearnley 12 years ago

Not being properly lubricated during sex causes it to hurt like a *beep* for most woman. The idea of someone violently shoving in a hard steel pipe, probably smashing into the cervix and doing heaps of damage inside, whilst the woman is tense, struggling and unstimulated (as she would be if she's unwilling) would be so excruciatingly painful. Plus the emotional trauma. Men, for perspective, think about how it would feel if someone roughly shoved a metal pipe up your ass, get some idea of what it would be like.

[–] cold2005 7 years ago

Or probably the biggest metal tube they could fit down into your PEEHOLE! That might be equivalent. I think men picturing that thought right now are cringing in pain ;)

[–] Duke-56 12 years ago

Duh....pipe up both areas....bloody....painful...all those U.N. people, ENGLAND company people, locals, relatives.....I just hope all those involved get their place in HELL and burn there for an eternity.

[–] camansega 12 years ago

PRAY THEY MUST AND HOPE THEY ATONE FOR WHAT THET DID BEFORE THEY DIE! Otherwise, yet, their very souls will burn in hell for eternity!

[–] Kookyburra 11 years ago

Some of the replies on this thread are truly sickening.

It really isn't hard to imagine that some of the people making jokes here would probably be the same cowards who would have done absolutely nothing and probably joined in the abuse if they were in that situation.

[–] evikeaz 11 years ago

I fast forwarded the torture scene as I couldn't possibly watch it whether it was explicit or not. Only thing I thought of is typical males..leading with their dicks *beep* to the ninth degree. Doesn't matter what religion or country they are from. Hanging them by the balls would be too far too lenient. these kinds of men deserve to be extinguished from the face of this earth. Unfortunately, there are too many men to take their place. It's always the men isn't it? Hmmmmm...

[–] 9 years ago

[deleted]

[–] MrAnonymous (145) 7 years ago

I assumed they forced it into her vagina (or anus). Absolutely brutal, but it must have terrified the other girls into complete submission.