MovieChat Forums > American Horror Story (2011) Discussion > Did anyone else only enjoy the first sea...

Did anyone else only enjoy the first season and fourth season?


In the entire series, Murder House and Freak show were the only ones with any value. Though I did enjoy the ''Sister Jude'' character from Asylum, the season itself was awful. The worst of all had to be Hotel (Oh God). What a terrible shame.

reply

I liked Murder House, but I didn't care for Freak Show. In fact, I liked Hotel more than Freak Show.

reply

1. Asylum
2. Murder House
3. Coven
4. Cult
5. Freak Show
6. Roanoke
7. Hotel

reply

1. Roanoke
2. Murder House
3. Coven
4. Freak Show
5. Hotel
6. Asylum
7. Cult

IMO The ONLY Bad season has been CULT

IMO Asylum Is By far The best overall season, Just not my favorite

Roanoke is My favorite, I love The Concept...I also enjoy the Paranormal Shows its based off of, I watch "A Haunting", "Paranormal State" and other similar shows so thats why I enjoy this season so much....

Murder House is Truly Special

Coven and Freakshow for me arent the typical AHS seasons, while they have shocking and twisted stuff happening they dont feel scary or twisted to me, They just feel like Great Stories

Cult is so far the ONLY season I have not rewatched and Probably never Will....Oddly enough its the reason I started watching AHS as I had zero interest in the series before, but The "Trump Election" storyline intrigued me....I watched the first 2 episodes, I liked them but stopped....about 2 months later I bought Murder House at a Pawn shop....Watched it and Was HOOKED....watched season 2 through 6 on Netflix in about a month(Literally Amazing, One of the best veiwing experiences of my life binging this series) then finished CULT ONLINE....but I struggled to get through Cult...

Its not awful, IMO Just not even close to all the other seasons....

Hotel Is the season that Feel Most UNLIKE AHS to me....I completely understand why AHS fans dont like it, But I really enjoyed it, again It had some fantastic stories and plots and incredible performances...

AHS is officially 1 of my favorite TV shows ever....I absolutely love that the same cast plays different characters every season....While it was a fantastic idea to do this, I think The Real Credit goes to the actors, I think They Struck GOLD With many of the Key Actors, Evans,Paulson,Bates, Lang and others are just PERFECT and were BORN for this series, I'm not sure the concept of having the same actors play different characters every season would have been this successful with different actors.

reply

I agree, only Murder House and Freak Show are good. I am not sure why Freak Show gets so much hate. It is the only season that had any heart. Asylum and Roanoke are the worst. I couldn't even get through Roanoke; that is how bad that one was.

reply

I hate asylum and Roanoke too!

reply