MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > Martin Scorsese says Marvel movies are '...

Martin Scorsese says Marvel movies are 'not cinema' - compares them to theme parks.


he is not a fan

https://www.theguardian.com/film/2019/oct/04/martin-scorsese-says-marvel-movies-are-not-cinema

reply

I love Scorsese, but I completely disagree with him. Marvel and other superhero movies are definitely cinema, and some of them are quite good.

reply

Cinema means the science and art of motion picture making so he is incorrect. He's an all time great director and he can think what he wants. But to paraphrase the boss of Marvel, the superhero movies have billion dollar grosses and pack theaters with excited fans

reply

Cinema means the science and art of motion picture making so he is incorrect.


No.

Cinema also has a language that distinguishes itself from other visual forms. This language is why sometimes when you walk out of a movie, you felt like you didn't watch a movie. You felt as if you had just watched a music video or a video game or a made-for-TV movie. The movie had nothing cinematic about it, so you came away feeling as if you hadn't seen a movie.

On the flip side, it's why you can watch a TV movie or play a video game and feel like it was "just like a movie." The movie or video game used the language of cinema, so you felt as if you were playing or watching a big screen movie.

reply

I politely disagree atomicgirl
If they are shooting and putting film in the can it is 'cinema'

Too many movie snobs 'pshaw' blockbuster movies in favor of artsy-fartsy type pictures...I like them all but I'm growing tired of movie fans that trash very good, enjoyable and exciting movies that are deemed 'lowbrow'

The Meg for instance was a ridiculously silly movie, but it was made to entertain and it sure did

Sometimes I enjoy a big silly thrill with lots of explosions but just as often I love a small, quiet film about people doing normal things

It's ALL cinema, I must disagree with you on this point

reply

Just had a look through his filmography and I don't see a lot of high concept themes there either. And no I am not a comic book/Marvel fan either.

reply

I avoid him and marvel.

reply

You don't like his 70s movies?

reply

I love "Taxi Driver", but I give the most credit to the writer (and a good director), Paul Schrader, who included every detail of the movie, as opposed to an outline... And I give the rest of the credit to Robert De Niro.

And he's made about 20 movies. I wouldn't even consider him a Top 50 director, and I could easily name better ones.

reply

I don't even like Taxi Driver. Goodfellas is ok but that would have been good anyway.

reply

I know where he’s coming from. The Marvel movies don’t take any chances.

reply

Fuck that.

Cheesy popular entertainment has been the primary focus of the film industry since the days of D.W. Griffith! Art films or message films have always been the afterthought, and that's something Scorscese probably doesnt want go admit, even to himself

reply

Old man syndrome.

reply

Me nerd me angry that old man hate comic book hero film grrrr goodfellas needed more explosions and comic references and bad improv humor grrr

reply

😊 😊 😊

reply