MovieChat Forums > Ringo Starr Discussion > The best drummer ever.

The best drummer ever.


The best drummer ever is John Bonham.

reply

Hahaha. See what you did there.

But in defense of Ringo, here's this:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LvIBr4-mDZU

reply

And in other tracks, including drum rolls, etc.

reply

I think this has to do with Ringo having his own sound rather than him being good.

reply

I'm not a big Beatles fan. And Ringo always came off as a goofball to me. I'm also not a musician though.

reply

BEST KNOWN DRUMMER FOR SURE.

reply

That’s what I’m saying. He’s the drummer, and he’s more famous than most.

reply

Forget about all those amateurs like Chick Webb, Gene Krupa, Buddy Rich, Sid Catlett, Dave Tough, Don Lamond, Joe Morello, and Louie Bellson.

reply

I'm a better drummer than Ringo and I don't even play the instrument.

reply

I'm not saying Ringo was bad. He was competent and did the job he was asked to do well enough. But to call him the best drummer ever is preposterous.

reply

As far as best goes, John Bonham could be the guy imo. Dad always said Ginger Baker was the best. Said he saw Zeppelin once and they were terrible, and he liked Zeppelin.

Imo, the best ROCK drummer ever is a difficult question, but I’ll just say Bonzo. He just had a great rhythmic sense, this mix of swing and heaviness.

Now on the other hand, the GREATEST rock drummer could indeed be Ringo. What other drummer has been as famous as he was back in those days?

Or does “best” mean “greatest” as well?

reply

You seem to imply that "greatest" means most famous.

reply

Well you have to be famous to make an impact.

reply

Imo, the best ROCK drummer ever is a difficult question, but I’ll just say Bonzo. He just had a great rhythmic sense, this mix of swing and heaviness.


I generally cite Bonham as the greatest rock drummer, but there are many others I would rank just as high, if not higher. A few of my favorites, often not mentioned in this conversation, would be Bill Ward (Black Sabbath), Nick Mason (Pink Floyd), & Danny Seraphine (Chicago).

Ringo is pretty good, but hardly the greatest.

reply

There are teenagers on YouTube playing drums better than anyone mentioned in this thread. 😆

reply

Lennon was once asked "Is Ringo the best drummer in the world?"
He replied "He's not even the best drummer in The Beatles"

that cracked me up

reply

He was a great fit for the Beatles.

reply

Bonham was good but most drummers would agree that Buddy Rich is the best ever and it's not even close. Rich did things on drums that didn't even seem humanly possible. Watch some of the YouTube videos of him soloing. Its some crazy stuff....

Although, many thought BR was kind of an asshole, his talent was undeniable.

reply

I've seen his videos. He's good but I feel like it was too much "look at me".

reply

Maybe so, but he did stuff that no one else can do. Rich was an amazing drummer even if he was a bit of an ass.

reply