MovieChat Forums > Saturday Night Fever (1977) Discussion > Stephanie - bad character or just bad ca...

Stephanie - bad character or just bad casting?


I'm almost sure that Stephanie wasn't meant to be such a dislikable character , but I see a lot of negativity in regards to her and the actress that plays her - even some going as far as to say that Tony was wrong to reject Annette and should've ended up with her instead - even though it's made pretty clear that Tony wants more out of life where Annette is content to make do. And according to her "it's only dancing" when to Tony it's clearly more than that.

So, enter Stephanie, who is supposed to be a kindred spirit sort of figure for Tony. She too wants to make something of herself and uses disco dancing as an escape from her everyday drudgery - okay, so she has a haughty demeanour and a backhanded way of "bettering herself", but I'm fairly certain it was the intention of the film makers to make her a pitiful character, rather than an actively disliked one - especially when it becomes obvious that she isn't as sophisticated as she pretends.

Aside from her snotty attitude, I see a lot of the problems people have with Stephanie include Karen Lynn Gorney's voice and the fact that she isn't that great of a dancer. So my question is: was Stephanie supposed to be an unsympathetic character or would she have been more likeable if she was played by another actress?



http://www.last.fm/user/DeleriumGirl

reply

Why would they cast a 32 year old woman (who definitely looked it) for that role? Wasn't the character supposed to be like 19 or 20?

reply

Yes, indeed. I thought she was one year older. However with her connections, the fact that she needed to be a bit better dancer didn't matter. I couldn't quite feel the chemistry. Now, take another older woman, Olivia Newton-John.... now that was perfect casting. I loved, "Grease." Not to be off topic, but it was great seeing Olivia as a judge on, "Dancing With the Stars."

Yes, the casting of Annette was spot on. Thank you (earlier in the thread) for pointing out the similarity in treatment with Tony and Annette with Stephanie and Tony. I've seen this movie 14 times, plus stage productions. I love the soundtrack and the Bee Gees music captured the Disco fever. 😅

reply

Would have loved to have seen Lindsay Wagner in this role. Don't know if she would have been too typecast for the role. She would have been 28 at the time and could have probably passed as early to mid 20's. 👌

Nobody goes there anymore. It's too crowded. Yogi Berra

reply

Actually in the film, at the coffeehouse, she claims to be older and wiser than Tony. Perhaps she was supposed to really be around 30.

reply

None of them are likeable though... the ex-priest maybe, but he's barely in it

reply