MovieChat Forums > The Thing (1982) Discussion > Why did the Thing alien even bother tryi...

Why did the Thing alien even bother trying to assimilate the men?


Ive seen the movie before dozens of times and one thing about the movie still bugs me.

Why did the alien even bother trying to assimilate the men out in the cold winter where they kept destroying the assimilated men/alien copies with flamethrowers and dynamite?

And if its intentions were trying to go back into outer space then why go after the men?

reply

We don't know it wanted to get back into outer space.

Maybe its survival strategy is just to take over as many organisms as possible. With only a few humans at McMurdo Station, its biological imperative was bound to go unsatisfied.

But the other posters have it right - it's an alien, so we don't know exactly what its priorities actually are.

Personally, I like to think that "The Thing," in its natural state, is just a single cell. Its sole imperative is to consume. It mimics solely to help it consume. Its mind is only as sophisticated as its current host.

reply

Oh no! You are ruining OP's thread with this sensible assessment! He's going to cuss!

reply

I think its intentions were to consume the world. It went after the men thinking it would just wait for supplies to arrive and it would hitch a ride to civilization from there. But its ass got discovered.

reply

^ this

reply

I would argue that it felt that this was the best case for two reasons: assimilating the men spread itself around (aka biological urge to pro-create) and if the men were burning the imitations so quickly, wouldn't it have a better chance of winning if the men were preoccupied with the assimilations instead of instantly burning the main Thing and winning with a first round KO?

reply

It's the Thing's nature to want to spread and take over other life forms.

reply

The Thing had to look like a man to repair the ship. He was using parts from the helicopter. He could not go about this work in his natural form.

reply

Just because it makes a saucer doesn't mean it wants to go to outer space. Just someplace else.

reply

I think the Thing had a biological need to feed and assimilate. Without that it would go into a dormant state or something.

reply

Now thinking of it, the Thing was stupid for assimilating all those dogs. It's what made the people suspicious. If it hadn't started assimilating all those dogs nobody would have gotten suspicious and tried finding ways to destroy it. It's almost like the Thing was just like, "I'm hungry and these other dogs look delicious. I don't care that it'll bring those other living beings directly here! I'm gonna eat cause I am so hungry!" Then it just does that bringing everyone running over there. If it hadn't done that and just assimilated the first person to check on the dogs the next morning, it would have been able to assimilate more people. But nope. It had to eat a bunch of dogs because it could only think with its stomach.

reply

I believe the other dogs would have noticed the Dog-Thing was an imitation and would have eventually attacked it or alerted their owners to its intentions. The dog-thing was acting in self defense at that point.

It also probably calculated that it had a better chance of survival by quickly absorbing the other dogs — as it knew the Americans had discovered what happened at the Norwegian camp and were going to probably test the dog-thing — but unfortunately for it Clark noticed the commotion.

reply

This might just be me but it seemed like the dogs didn't react to it until it started making unnatural noises that weren't anything like the sound a dog makes.

reply

You're right about that. Initially when the new dog was put in with the other dogs they were absolutely fine. Suddenly the new dog started making unnatural noises and motions and that's when the other dogs started barking, howling and desperately trying to get away.

reply