MovieChat Forums > The Right Stuff (1984) Discussion > Was anyone else disturbed by Shepherd's ...

Was anyone else disturbed by Shepherd's impressions?


He did impressions of Mexican-Americans, even in front of Mexican-Americans. What was that about? Did I miss something there? I can't even understand why that was in the film.

reply

This thread goes to show how stupid political correctness is.
I have watched this film many times, and I love the impression that the Shepard character does. I always get a good laugh out of it.
Shepard didn't do the impression to be meanspirited or racist. He did it to be funny.
Political Correctness is stupid and only fans the flames of racism. I think we all need to relax and stop looking for ways to be offended.
But today's generation was raised to be offended, it seems.

reply

If they were raised that way, they aren't to blame. Place the blame an THE PEOPLE THAT RAISED THEM! Might that be YOUR generation?

reply

Pay attention to the beginning to the movie when Harry Shearer and Jeff Goldblum are in the Motel Room. You can see Bill Dana's Routine on TV. That scene sets it up so you understand what Alan Shepard was doing.

reply

lighten up Francis.

Do you whine on comedian's pages when they make fun of white people?

reply

The minor subplot of Jose Jimenez was included to show how different social standards were in the late 1950s/early 60s to the mid 80s.

Remember, in 1958-59 when the Mercury astronauts were selected, we were barely more than a decade from white audiences laughing uproariously at shuck-and-jive blackface comedians.

It's a change for the better. Racism ain't that funny.

reply

I was not disturbed no.

reply

But racial and ethnic humor is. And just because you tell that kind of joke, it doesn't make you racist. It wasn't that long ago that the American people were much more ethnically"pure". There wasn't nearly as much mixing of race and ethnicity as there is today. And most cities were quite segregated. Just about every city had a <insert ethnicity here> town. The Italians had there part of town, the WASPs their's, the Irish their's, the Chinese, Japanese, Latinos theirs and the long time Americans theirs. And the Poles had Chicago. So there were all kinds of jokes made at the stereotype images of each ethnicity. And nobody seemed to care, because pretty much everybody did it. Today, people go around looking for any excuse to be OUTRAGED! Witness the OP.

reply

"Was anyone else disturbed by Shepherd's impressions?"

Um... no. How about, HELL no. My God, cry me a river. No, better yet, grow some thicker skin. Like others have said here - it is historically accurate.



Oh... I can get us there real fast... Jack Butler's gonna like you.

reply

For several years, Bill Dana, a comedy writer, hit it very big with the Jose Jimenez character, which was first introduced in the "Man on the street" segment of THE STEVE ALLEN SHOW. He sold many, many comedy albums and even starred in a two-season sitcom on NBC, THE BILL DANA SHOW, in which Jose was a bumbling bellhop in a New York hotel. His co-stars were Jonathan Harris (pre-LOST IN SPACE) and Don Adams (pre-GET SMART). In fact, the Adams character, the hotel's detective, was a prototype for Maxwell Smart. I think Dana was credited for creating the "Would you believe?" jokes for Adams' stand-up routine. Because of changing mores, Dana retired "Jose" in the early 70's. Dana also wrote one of the more famous episodes of ALL IN THE FAMILY, the visit from Sammy Davis, Jr.
As an old fart, I can assure you that Alan Shepard wasn't the only Jose Jimenez" imitator in the 1960's. I had an uncle who loved doing Jose and "Parkyakarkus." Who dat? Oh, another "ethnic" comic who happened to be the father of Albert Brooks.

reply

Didn't bother me; he was immitating Bill Dana. It's funny (esp. Gonzalez' reaction)

"What do you want me to do, draw a picture? Spell it out!"

reply

I always knew he was doing a bit he'd seen on TV, a bit that was fairly popular way back then.

Blood never lies.

reply

Not at all..It is good to poke fun at people...Folks now a days are way to sensitive..

You Have a Hard Lip, Herbert..

Better Living Thru Chemistry

reply

I guess, by that standard, I can poke fun at white people like yourself and not suffer any repercussions.. Want me do do so? I promise you, it won't be very nice.

reply

Feel free to poke fun at me, I will probably laugh...Im a Blonde too....If you are confident a little humor your way will not hurt you, if you are weak it will...People who get offended easily are just plain weak....I poke back...lol

You Have a Hard Lip, Herbert..

Better Living Thru Chemistry

reply

Once again, another know-nothing, humorless voice cries out from the PC peanut gallery.

reply