MovieChat Forums > She's Out of My League (2010) Discussion > Name One Movie That Has a #5 Girl Get a...

Name One Movie That Has a #5 Girl Get a Guy Who’s a #10?


Just asking. I think in Hollywood that would be considered Science Fiction. SWAMP THING does not count.

reply

Strange Days (Juliette Lewis and Ralph Fiennes)
Maid in Manhattan (Jennifer Lopez and, again, Ralph Fiennes)
whatever movie Whoopi Goldberg starred in with Ted Danson (she isn't even a 5 IMO, and they were a real-life couple, too)
Woody Allen's Match Point (Emily Mortimer and Jonathan Rhys Meyers)
Transsiberian (Emily Mortimer and Woody Harrelson)
Sex & the City (Sarah Jessica Parker and John Corbett / Ron Livingston / Chris Noth and multiple random good-looking guys, such as Bradley Cooper and Justin Theroux)
Up in the Air (Vera Farmiga and George Clooney)
Knight & Day (Cameron Diaz and Tom Cruise - not that Cameron is a 5, but she definitely doesn't compare favorably to Tom Cruise)
Spread (Ashton Kutcher and Margarita Levieva - I mean, she is attractive, but kinda a butterface, especially compared to Ashton)
White Men Can't Jump (Rosie Perez and Woody Harrelson)

I am sure I can come up with many more if I think about it.

And how about real-life couples?

Hugh Jackman and his wife
Brandon Routh (the latest Superman guy) and his wife
the above-mentioned Bradley Cooper was in a relationship with Renee Zellweger until recently
Jay Baruchel and his fiancee, Alison Pill (in my opinion, he is around a 7, and she is... below 0)
Ashton Kutcher and Demi Moore? not that she is a 5, but she was never in the same league looks-wise


This hardly falls in the realm of science fiction, dude.




My karma ran over your dogma.

reply

Cant agree abt "Maid in Manhattan" AT ALL !!!

What abt " P.S I love you " ....

Also, "Mrs.Winterbourne", where a suave and hunky Brendan Fraser falls in love
with a plump n plain-ish girl.




reply

P.S. I Love You - I don't know, maybe. I mean, generally I'd say that Gerard Butler is hot, and Hilary Swank is not. However, in that particular movie they were about the same level of attractiveness, no? He had that stupid hair (not to mention that he could stand to lose a few), I really didn't feel he was anything special there.

Mrs. Winterbourne - is that the one with Ricki Lake? It's been a long time since I've seen it. Yes, definitely.

As for Maid in Manhattan, it was more about their behavior for me. She was a little too "from the people", whereas he was so refined and aristocratic - I felt they weren't even remotely in the same league. Nor am I a fan of that ass, for that matter.



reply

Superman: Christopher Reeve could be a 10 compared to Margo Kitter who was Lois Lane..

La Bamba: Lou Diamond Phillips could be a 10 compared to the girl who played Donna who was no hotter than a 5

Sex and the City: Carrie Bradshaw was a 2 while Adian and Big were about 8's.



We created the missionary position. ... You're welcome!

reply

I do not agree with you completely.
Carrie Bradshaw is not a #5 character but a #8 or #9,
(and so is SJP, I don't care what Maxim says, they are so wrong).
Demi Moore was and still is stunning to me, no matter what she has done to her body.
Renee is also very pretty IMO
I looked up Allison Pill and I find it kinda harsh that she is below 0 to you, she has a fresh and natural face, maybe not a #10 but about #7 or 8.
Brandon Routh's wife?! She's so beautiful! Or were you talking about Brandon being a 5?

reply

Brandon Routh is pure perfection. His wife is nowhere near in the same league.


reply

Mrs. Winterbourne. Ricki Lake lands Brendan Fraser.

reply

BEST EXAMPLE: Transformers 1,2,3.

Shia Lebeouf and Megan Fox
Shia Lebeouf and Rosie Huntington

Nuff said.

If you've got an ass I'll kick it!!! - Wimp Lo

reply

Nia Vardolos isn't even half as good looking as the college professor who we're supposed to believe falls for her. Film did big box office too.

reply

There are plenty of movies where a cute dorky girl gets the hot jock.

reply

Yes, and the OP is asking you to name just one.


I only do it with superheroes.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

my big fat greek wedding

reply

On "Curb Your Enthusiasm" Larry David is always having sex with women that are much better looking than he is.

reply

[deleted]



Randy Couture: A Combat Legend
Thanks for the battles

reply