Did he kill Caleb?

Of course he killed him. Whilst the ending doesn't explicitly state so, I'm sure he did, and that he had to! I'm convinced Caleb would have killed Loomis otherwise. Caleb was overly keen to start, and then finish the 'water project' at which point he would have disposed of Loomis shortly thereafter. The home would then have had power and he and Ann a decent chance at survival. Whether he cared for Ann is suspect, but Loomis would only have been a threat either way, and Caleb wanted to survive too (which only adds to the point that he wouldn't just leave, and likely to his quick death). So Loomis had to kill him, or that's how I see it, and I got the impression Ann knew Caleb was dead.

Aside the moment Caleb appears to point his gun at the back of Loomis' head, I think the story about the mine, if any truth to it, may well have been that Caleb was the one that killed the others to survive... As I said, he had to kill Caleb.

Dude, remove the spoiler in your title.


That's the thing about life...nobody gets out alive.

Conversely, the empty fridge revealed (once Loomis reappeared, that is) that Caleb did in fact take food for his journey.

When John went back to the house he said that Caleb was leaving to Anson, and told Anna that Caleb said that she would welcome if he was gone or leaving. After all Caleb said that he was not believed that John was a jealousy person that statement considered that John was alright or okay with Caleb being there and stayed for a long time, but Caleb didn't believed that.

And also when John said that Ann would welcome if Caleb would gone Ann doesn't reacted anything at all or there were no suspicious condition or mimic from her face that were meant Ann already knew when Caleb said that.

So the conclusion is Caleb was gone to Anson with John suit.

Loomis definitely killed Caleb. There is no way Caleb would have voluntarily left such a perfect situation in order to put himself in a most likely certain death situation. Ann had chosen him. Both he and Loomis knew it and that's why they both knew Loomis was already the third wheel.

Wow! SUPER spoilery thread title, dude.

i think when he save his life celab have a shock what just happened.who he thinks that hate him save his life. he thinks that he own him something the best thing to do is go away he knows that anna doesn't love him all that stuff so that's why he left. if loomis want him dead he left the rope on the first time celab left with the suit i think. celab left his stuff there because he don't want that anna notice that and ask him and stop him...

I think if you're willing to look at the symbolism and, what do they call it... ACTING in the last few scenes it's clear he killed Caleb.

Loomis and Ann's behavior, her scene pushing the glass off, his scene stepping to the edge as if contemplating suicide, his return to the church, and most obviously his re-creating the church in the barn for her as an expression of guilt and looking for salvation. Not only did he realize how special she was because Caleb came, he also "found God" through Caleb.

I think knowing who Caleb was in the Bible makes this make sense, too - I had to look it up but once I did it fit.