No, it's not.
Imagine a family of 4, parents and 2 kids. The Snap happens, one parent and one kid disappear. 5 years pass, the 2 remaining have grieved and moved on, maybe the parent even remarried, maybe even remarried with someone displaced from a high population and poor area as immigrant to the USA, maybe the kid died one year later in a car accident. Life went forward.
And now the asshole avengers bring the blip, and the people that disappeared 5 years ago reaper and for them everything happened like ... 1 second ago, not 5 years. Can you imagine all the pain and the fucked up situations that the world is open to? I had a job, a family, a life one second ago but now I have nothing, been declared dead, my wife forgot about me already, etc. And the wife ... after moving on and having another husband, maybe another kid with the new husband, suddenly has her old husband back as well, who doesn't understand wtf is going on, etc. And that is happening FOR HALF OF THE WORLD. "Honey, i haven't seen you since breakfast but i love you so much" "WTF? You've been dead for 5 years, who are you? why are you doing this to me?"
What about the people that were flying at the moment of the snap ... did they just splat on the asphalt from 10.000 feet? Or sailing ... did they just become shark food?
If they did the blip, they should have done it then, right after the snap, not 5 years later ... specially when they can move around time how the fuck they want to.
reply
share
ManToTrust (1657)
3 years ago
Strange would’ve ran that scenario. Remember? Obviously if they tried to intervene with the original snap it wouldn’t have worked.
reply
share
asom (6611)
3 years ago
There's no scenario to run. As seen in the show, the blip brought a LOT of problems.
People would have re-appeared in the same spatial position. Can you imagine millions of people appearing out of thin air in the middle of highways at 80mph???
And I'm not even bringing the fact that in 5 years the planet itself would have traveled in space quire a bit.
All the people would have re-appeared somewhere in the middle of an empty space between planets or maybe even inside the sun.
Basic physics .. I know, doesn't apply in super hero movies :D
But even ignoring the basic physics, the implication of half of population re-appearing after 5 years are immense - again, the show goes a bit into that.
reply
share
Alex (1495)
3 years ago
They coulda blipped them all back 25 days later after they killed original Thanos, how about that?
Infinity gauntlet is capable of unwinding time, changing reality, restoring people, bringing back the dead (except soulstone sacrifice ofc), etc. It's basically over 9000.
Plus Strange didn't tell Stark that he needs to be a selfish bastard and protect his future kid to be at the cost of 3,5 billion displaced people. That's the real reason, plot driving scene in Endgame. The current show is still dealing with those consequences, having to move millions of refugees back to their original countries, the reason for Karli and her flag smashers motivation.
reply
share
Alex (1495)
3 years ago
Just a minor correction - quantum time machine doesn't let you move back and forth in your Earth 1 timeline, but rather create separate timelines that will not affect your own.
However, the infinity stones do not have that limitations and they coulda reset timeline as they see fit but Tony specifically told Bruce to "bring everyone back now, but don't change anything in the past. Restore what we lost, but keep what we have now" (implying his daughter ofcourse).
reply
share
faqbaby (54)
3 years ago
I feel like mcu should just make a random drama based movie about the blip without focusing too much on the superhero element.
reply
share